top of page

New March Survey: Small Business Owners Back Away from Recession Fears; Gen Z Gets Failing Labor Market Report Card

Survey of 80,000 small business owners examines Tik Tok Ban, crypto currency, hiring trends, inflation, impacts of a Fed rate cut, & more 


The March edition of the Freedom Economy Index survey (FEI) was released today, finding that small business owners have taken a significant step back from their recession fears, but also aren’t posturing for big growth...yet. The survey, a joint project of PublicSquare and RedBalloon, sampled 80,000 small business owners from March 15-19. 


Key Takeaways 


  1. Recession fears are easing. 67% of employers believe the US will head into a recession, down from 78% in February, and the lowest reading in 8 months. At the same time, positive sentiment moved only slightly from February. Most employers said they are shelving any staffing change plans, and respondents indicated they’re holding their cash, making only the most essential purchases. 


“Small business owners are clearly feeling a turning in the economy,” said PublicSquare CEO Michael Seifert. “But they’re not willing to bet the farm just yet on which direction the economy will turn next.” 


2. Gen Z Doesn’t Make the Grade.  Employers gave a failing report card to Gen Z in the workplace, with: 

  • 68% of small business owners find Gen Zers to be the “least reliable” of all their employees. 

  • 71% of employers say Gen Z is the most likely group to have a workplace mental health issue.  

  • Less than 4% say that Gen Z is the generation that “most aligns with their workplace culture.” 

  • 62% say Gen Z is the most likely group to cause division and toxicity in the workplace.  

  • 57% say Gen Z is the most likely group to post a risk of a workplace lawsuit.

“The 2024 labor market will be one of the most difficult in decades,” said Andrew Crapuchettes, CEO of “With large scale retirements by baby boomers, the market needs an influx of new talent, but Gen Z is clearly struggling to make the grade.” 

3. Reliability Drought. 70% of employers said that “lack of reliability” is their top problem when hiring, and 60% of employers said they’d rather be under-staffed with less people, less problems, but more hours for the business owners, than poorly staffed with more employees but more problems.   


“The labor market is a tough battleground right now, and it’s weighing heavily on employers who need talent to both maintain their operations and to grow for the future,” continued Crapuchettes. 


4. Employers are Stressed Out. One quarter of small business owners said that their exhaustion level in this economy is ten out of ten, and another 35% said they’re at an 8 or 9. 


“The Biden economy has taken its toll on these small business owners,” Seifert said.  “They’re ready for stability and positive sustained direction in our economy. If the White House is serious about the upcoming election, they’ll be paying attention.” 


5. Divisions Over Banning Tik Tok. Small business owners are keenly aware of, and sharply divided over, the bill in congress to ban Tik Tok.  35% have heard of the legislation and are supportive.  41% are opposed. Just 2.2% say they haven’t heard of the issue. 


“There are strong sensitivities over free speech and banning voices, particularly after all the activity by the US government to ban doctors and others on social media during the pandemic and 2020 election,” said RedBalloon Communications Director Isaac Lopez. “So, it makes sense that the house is divided over the Tik Tok ban.” 



Small businesses sense that the economy is at an inflection point. They’re holding their cards and waiting for the right moment to either spring into growth mode, or retract into a defensive posture. Fewer business owners now feel we’re headed to a major recession, but most are uncertain of exactly where this economy is going. 


The labor market continues to be a challenge, with retirements accelerating among boomers and working-aged sideline sitters still unmoved. Gen Z so far offers little relief. In fact, employers sound as if they’d rather skip hiring Gen Z and go with the difficulties of being “under-staffed” than hire Gen Z and endure the challenges associated with that generation. 


One thing is certain: it’s been a grueling economy under the Biden Administration, and small business owners are exhausted. They’re also alarmed at the accumulation rate of federal debt. Still Americans are resilient, and the small business community stands ready to fearlessly face whatever our future may bring. At PublicSquare and RedBalloon, we stand with them as the Freedom Economy continues to grow in numbers and reach. 



The Freedom Economy Index surveyed a universe of over 80,000 small business owners throughout the United States, fielding the questionnaire from March 15-19, 2024, with 839 respondents. The survey has a margin of error of +/-3.0% at the 95% confidence level. Download the March report here. 

4,111 views0 comments


bottom of page